Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tim Maness's avatar

Thanks, Ed! In this post I see you wrestling with two imperatives that stand in tension, and maybe that’s part of what it means to be a good dialectical theologian. I deeply respect the way you take seriously what Paul would have called the dangers of a teaching role: wanting to give good, healing, trustworthy advice, while avoiding insofar as possible the sin that lies within even our best intentions. This may be one of those situations in which Luther might have advised us to “sin boldly”: to work out this dialectic between self-denial and rejecting self-hatred in fear and trembling, and to live by the results of our struggles as best we can, for we know that despite our proneness to sin and error, the grace of God is at work in us.

Expand full comment
Greg's avatar

Someone wrote “The charge is to hold onto your faith until you die.” That’s from memory, so not the least authority behind it.

I think that the self-denial is required to hold on to faith; the hours will come when only blind holding will yield to confirmation, and at those times all hopes for “self” must die — but to be reborn as a self somewhat more steeped in the faith and thus somewhat better suited to spreading the word of Christ.

I went conservative evangelical upbringing (witness the key word) to Kierkegaard to Wittgenstein (mostly slow study of PI and later works) CD 1/2 (for years) and then finally the rest of CD.

Thanks for this 🙏

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts